Am Law 200 Firm Reshapes Outsourcing, Equipment and Cost Recovery Strategy Post-COVID for Substantial Savings and Increase in Recoveries.

Headquartered on the East Coast this Am Law 200 firm has 496 attorneys and 700 support staff across 21 offices. Leadership wanted to analyze renewal options for the firm’s managed services as well as options to refresh the MFD fleet for 8 of the firm’s offices.

OPPORTUNITY
Headquartered on the East Coast this Am Law 200 firm has 496 attorneys and 700 support staff across 21 offices. Leadership wanted to analyze renewal options for the firm’s managed services as well as options to refresh the MFD fleet for 8 of the firm’s offices.

Mattern met with the firm’s leadership at the outset of the engagement to discuss the firm’s objectives which included:

- Streamlined services
- Right-sizing of both staffing and equipment needs
- Maintain or improve service levels and contract terms
- Consider alternatives to staff positions (print support specialist and dedicated messenger)
- Ensure all aspects of the services most important to the firm are addressed – both current state and post-COVID prognosis
- At Mattern’s recommendation, the firm also included an analysis of the current cost recovery strategy to investigate the impact of the shift to hybrid operations on volumes.

PROCESS
Mattern performed a comprehensive review of the firm’s outsourced staff and the services provided by the current service provider, Ricoh, along with the firm’s MFD fleet based on pre-COVID and COVID usage.

Based upon Mattern’s evaluation and utilizing our industry knowledge and benchmarks, Mattern made key recommendations that would reduce costs, improve service levels, right-size staff and equipment, create efficiencies in staffing and equipment utilization, and with a change in strategy, increase the recovery of costs. These recommendations included:

- Reduce current outsourced headcount by 4 FTEs across 4 offices as well as add 1 FTE in an office previously not outsourced
- Eliminate stand-alone facsimiles, implement desktop faxing and equip MFDs with facsimile capabilities
- Evaluate alternatives to current embedded Equitrac cost recovery software and capture and recover for all output/input (copy/print/scan)
- Right-size MFD fleet based on current and anticipated output needs
- Mattern created the Request for Proposal (RFP) which captured the recommendations from the evaluation process. The RFP was sent to three (3) labor and equipment service providers, including Ricoh, and one equipment-only service provider.

RESULTS
After reviewing the responses and meeting with a short-list of service providers, the firm decided to continue their partnership with Ricoh for labor but elected to change providers for the equipment portion to capture savings and improve flexibility.

Dex Imaging was selected to refresh the MFDs with a fleet of A3 devices, provide maintenance across all output equipment, and provide a new, embedded cost recovery solution.The current Rioch contract was amended to reflect the following for a savings of 13%:

- Reduction of overall headcount by 4 FTEs
- Realignment of staffing positions to meet print support and messenger needs
- Updated service level agreements

The new contract with Dex Imaging encompassed output equipment and software resulted in a cost savings of 27% in equipment:

- Reduction of the MFD fleet by 13% by providing a mix of A3 (MFD) devices
- Increase in the available contracted equipment flexibility from 20% to 50%
- Elimination of stand-alone facsimiles and equipped MDFs with faxing capabilities
- Replacement of embedded Equitrac with PaperCut, reducing software cost, and enhancing reporting capabilities for an increased internal oversight of the copy/print operations.
- In conjunction with the above changes and as part of the engagement recommendations, the firm was exploring the modification of their cost recovery strategy to capture and recover all output (copy/print/scan), which would result in a projected increase in recovery costs of over $2,000,000 per year, an increase of (132%).

In discussing the project, the Director of Administration stated “We have worked with Mattern Associates for many years. They truly have our firm’s best interests at heart; all bases are always covered with excellent and comprehensive attention to detail and appropriate follow-up.” – Director of Administration

The procurement of office supplies is back to pre-pandemic levels and firms are once again looking to optimize their spend. After years of decline due to hybrid work and the shift to digital output, the overall dollar spend is back, or in some cases, exceeding pre-pandemic levels.

AmLaw 200 Firm Streamlines Procurement and Saves 43% on Office Supplies

Establishing and maintaining a successful contract negotiation is a situation in which there needs to be two winners, not a winner and a loser. While every firm wants to procure the best contracts through informed negotiation, it is also important to preserve the long term, industry relationships with the vendors. You’ve got to pick the competitors wisely, and you must know the best practices in your region. To that end, there’s a great deal of strategy involved in an Open RFP; one might say an art.

Prominent IP Law Firm Achieves Win-Win & 10 Year Contract with Open Off-Site Records RFP

With more than 1,100 lawyers and consulting professionals in 24 offices worldwide, this firm is a leading business and litigation practice with global reach. As is the trend with many successful large firms, this particular one had undergone a merger in 2009 with an established Atlanta-based firm.

National Firm Gains 33% Reduction in Permanent Withdrawal Fees and 22% Monthly Savings on Outsourcing Contracts in Dual RFPs

Best Best & Krieger, LLP is a 180-attorney law firm that has been in business for more than a century. The firm has grown to include several dynamic practice groups across eight offices throughout California.

Mattern & Associates Spearheads Vendor Consolidation, Achieves 23% Monthly Savings in Support Services for Best Best & Krieger

Established in 1891, Best Best & Krieger (BBK) is a highly regarded, full-service law firm of over 350 professionals, including more than 200 attorneys across nine offices in California and in Washington, D.C. Maria D’Aquila is the firm’s Operations Manager.

Mattern’s Phase III Contract Compliance Program Achieves Maximum Value for Best Best & Krieger’s Office Supplies Contracts

This 320 attorney, AmLaw 200, Houston-based firm was in the throes of implementing a “work-cell” environment for their secretaries per practice area. The restructuring of staff and office layout required a different output strategy to be deployed in order to provide the tools and technology within close proximity to the work-cells, while also looking to reduce expenses. However, the firm had several expiration dates for their existing multi-function devices, requiring a creative plan for addressing replacements that also substantially improved the convenience and efficiency for the new work-cell environment.

AmLaw 200 Firm Shifts to Work-Cell Environment, Captures 24% in Cost Savings while Substantially Improving Operational Efficiency

This AmLaw 200, Chicago-based firm had taken advantage of outsourcing methods over the last couple of years; however, its current outsourcing and equipment contract was soon to expire. Since the firm renewed with the incumbent vendor the previous five years, they were interested in learning what other service bureaus were providing in the outsourcing marketplace. The firm also desired to determine whether they were staffed appropriately and operating under industry best practices and service levels with competitive pricing.

Chicago-based Firm Improves Workflow and Achieves 33% Annual Savings

This 250 attorney, Am Law 200, Washington D.C.-based firm had specific areas in which it was struggling; in particular, they were finding it difficult to keep current with technology, flexing to meet demand, and recovering costs for the internal systems and storage related to litigation support services (e-Discovery).

Am Law 200 Firm Gains Competitive Advantage and Charge Back Model to Recoup Costs for eDiscovery Managed Services

This 350 attorney, Am Law 200 firm based in Ohio had decided to outsource their in-sourced back-office operations and multi-function devices (MFDs) on a firm-wide basis five years prior. The contract was expiring and the firm was now considering outsourcing the on-site centralized Records and Information Management functions. As a result, the firm was interested in what other outsourcing companies’ capabilities were in the records space, how they may improve current services to the firm, and whether they had a competitive contract.

Am Law 200 Firm Saves on Costs, Improves Service Levels by Outsourcing Records and Selecting New MFD Vendor

This 250 attorney, AmLaw 200, Washington D.C.-based firm has 11 offices nationwide. The firm had multiple offsite records storage contracts in place and was interested in investigating cost-savings and efficiencies by consolidating vendors as well as creating a short and long-term strategy to reduce their offsite storage commitments.

Am Law 200 Firm Removes Permanent Withdrawal Fees, Consolidates Vendors and Saves 24% in Off-Site Record Storage

This 225 attorney, Nashville-based firm was looking to improve outsourcing workflow efficiencies, service level and increase equipment capabilities. The firm had been with its current outsourcing and equipment provider for over a decade and felt that the level of off-site management interaction and proactive presentation of strategic initiatives were minimal.

Nashville-based Firm Improves Outsourcing Workflow Efficiencies, Service and Equipment Capabilities: Achieves 51% Savings