How Does a 326% Increase Sound to You?
Using Mattern’s benchmark data and experience from prior off-site records negotiations, Mattern developed a negotiation strategy and worked behind the scenes with the Firm through a series of tactical responses and counterproposals designed to bring pricing and contractual terms back to competitive market levels.

OPPORTUNITY
326% — that was the increase this Minneapolis-based law firm experienced in off-site records storage pricing after its contract expired.
Once the agreement lapsed, the Firm became subject to annual Schedule A increases across multiple service items. In addition, the Firm was incurring repeated and largely unchecked re-boxing and re-lidding charges.
Over time, the cumulative impact was significant, leaving the Firm with pricing well above competitive market levels and limited contractual protection against future increases.
The Firm engaged Mattern to review and benchmark its current pricing and recommend a strategy to improve both its costs and contractual position.
PROCESS
Mattern benchmarked the Firm’s current pricing against the Mattern Method® Benchmarks and Best Practices and evaluated whether a competitive procurement process would produce the best result.
Unfortunately, permanent withdrawal charges had also increased substantially. Those costs made moving the Firm’s inventory to another provider economically impractical and effectively limited the Firm’s negotiating leverage.
Rather than recommend an RFP that was unlikely to produce a viable alternative, Mattern recommended a closed negotiation with the incumbent provider.
Using Mattern’s benchmark data and experience from prior off-site records negotiations, Mattern developed a negotiation strategy and worked behind the scenes with the Firm through a series of tactical responses and counterproposals designed to bring pricing and contractual terms back to competitive market levels.
RESULTS
At the conclusion of the negotiations, the Firm executed a new three-year agreement that:
- Reduced projected pricing by approximately 50% compared with what the Firm otherwise would have paid
- Replaced average annual increases of approximately 21% with contractual increases capped at 5%
- Provided pricing certainty for the next three years
- Improved the Firm’s overall contractual position and protection against uncontrolled future increases
Following completion of the engagement, the client was asked whether its overall situation — including internal policies, vendor performance, pricing, and contractual terms — had significantly improved as a result of Mattern’s involvement. The client responded “Yes” and gave Mattern a Net Promoter Score of 10 out of 10, commenting: “Friendly, professional assistance.”
Based on the circumstances of this engagement, Mattern’s fee was structured as a percentage of the decreased costs achieved, putting the Firm in a position to pay only when measurable savings were successfully realized.
MATTERN NOTE
This engagement illustrates one of the biggest risks in off-site records storage: allowing an agreement to expire while inventory remains effectively captive with the incumbent provider.
Once a contract expires, annual market-rate increases can compound quickly, while permanent withdrawal charges can make changing providers prohibitively expensive.
Firms should closely monitor contract expiration dates, negotiate renewal terms well in advance, and ensure that pricing, annual escalations, withdrawal charges, re-boxing fees, re-lidding fees, and other miscellaneous charges are clearly defined and controlled throughout the term of the agreement.
Mattern Leads Strategic Outsourcing for AmLaw 25 Firm, Lowering Costs and Enhancing Services
To elevate service quality and secure more competitive pricing, this global AmLaw 25 firm needed to refresh more than a decade-old outsourcing model across multiple administrative and support functions. Mattern partnered with the firm to restructure leadership, optimize staffing, and integrate technology, ultimately delivering savings of more than 10% and reducing off-site facility costs by 71%—all while strengthening vendor accountability and aligning operations with the firm’s long-term strategic goals.
A PilotLegis Member Firm Streamlines Off-Site Records and Establishes Firmwide Information Governance
This PilotLegis member firm engaged Mattern to address two interconnected risks: a growing off-site records footprint and the absence of a firmwide information governance framework. By pairing a historical records cleanup with practical IG policy development, the firm took a disciplined approach to reducing legacy paper risk while establishing clear, defensible practices for the future. The result was a coordinated strategy that delivered immediate cost and risk reduction while setting the foundation for long-term governance maturity.
Mattern Revamps Nonprofit’s Off-Site Records Program, Cutting Storage Costs by 82%
There is a way out.
Typically, Mattern works with law firms but when a former client called from their new role at a nonprofit and asked for help with a long-troubled off-site records program, Mattern didn’t hesitate. The nonprofit organization had tried for years to improve the situation without success. Mattern stepped in to deliver clarity, competition, and control.
Strategic Scanning Initiative Enables Seamless Office Move for National Law Firm
A national law firm preparing for a major office relocation needed a structured, defensible way to reduce its physical records footprint without disrupting attorney workflows. Mattern designed and managed a comprehensive scanning initiative that aligned with the Firm’s information governance objectives and ensured all work was completed before the move. The result was a streamlined transition that strengthened long-term records management practices.
Future-Ready Legal Operations: How Mattern Helped a Leading Law Firm Optimize Outsourcing, Technology, and Governance
To stay ahead of shifting demands, this California-based NLJ 500 firm needed to align its outsourcing, equipment, and information governance practices with a hybrid work environment. Mattern helped the firm optimize operations, strengthen policy, and secure long-term stability across 12 offices—all while recovering the full cost of the engagement.
.png)










