A Two-Year Off-site Storage Dispute: Resolved in a Week with 50% Savings
How Mattern reduced an $868,191 off-site records storage settlement demand by more than 50% and secured a full release of claims.

OPPORTUNITY
A Philadelphia-based law firm faced a significant dispute with its longtime off-site records storage provider.
After the firm’s contract expired, disagreements arose over annual price escalations and various miscellaneous charges. As a result, the firm stopped paying its monthly invoices while the parties attempted to resolve the dispute.
At the same time, the firm determined that approximately 99% of the records being stored at the provider’s facility were eligible for destruction without any additional internal review.
The service provider ultimately demanded $868,191 to settle the account, including past-due invoices and destruction charges. After nearly two years of negotiations, the parties remained at an impasse.
PROCESS
The firm engaged Mattern based on successful contract negotiations Mattern had previously completed on its behalf.
Mattern reviewed the expired agreement, analyzed the disputed charges, and applied its proprietary benchmark data and experience from prior off-site records negotiations to determine what it believed represented a fair and supportable settlement.
Mattern then developed a settlement strategy, presented its recommended offer to the firm for approval, and took the lead in negotiating with the storage provider.
The objective was straightforward: demonstrate why accepting the Mattern-developed settlement was in the provider’s best interest and bring a long-running dispute to a final resolution.
The provider accepted the firm-approved settlement offer within one week.
RESULTS
The firm ultimately paid less than 50% of the provider’s original $868,191 demand and received a full release of all claims.
The engagement resolved a dispute that had remained open for nearly two years, substantially reduced the firm’s financial exposure, and allowed it to close out the relationship with the storage provider on favorable terms.
Just as importantly, Mattern’s compensation was entirely performance-based. Mattern was paid only upon the successful completion of the negotiation and received only a percentage of the savings actually realized by the firm. This structure aligned Mattern’s interests directly with the client’s and ensured that the firm incurred no consulting fee unless measurable savings were achieved.
MATTERN NOTE: LESSONS LEARNED
Having seen many firms encounter similar situations, there are several important lessons:
- Do not allow your contract to lapse. An expired agreement can expose the firm to market-rate increases, unfavorable pricing changes, and reduced leverage in future negotiations.
- Receiving market-rate Schedule A pricing does not mean the firm is properly under contract. Pricing, annual escalations, service charges, and other key financial terms should be clearly defined for each year of the agreement.
- Communicate early and document everything. Maintain a written record of all discussions, disputes, pricing changes, commitments, and proposed resolutions to ensure clarity, avoid misunderstandings, and protect the firm’s interests.
If your firm finds itself in a similar standoff with its off-site records provider, consider seeking guidance from an independent third party with expertise in market pricing, contract terms, and negotiation leverage.
Mattern Leads Strategic Outsourcing for AmLaw 25 Firm, Lowering Costs and Enhancing Services
To elevate service quality and secure more competitive pricing, this global AmLaw 25 firm needed to refresh more than a decade-old outsourcing model across multiple administrative and support functions. Mattern partnered with the firm to restructure leadership, optimize staffing, and integrate technology, ultimately delivering savings of more than 10% and reducing off-site facility costs by 71%—all while strengthening vendor accountability and aligning operations with the firm’s long-term strategic goals.
A PilotLegis Member Firm Streamlines Off-Site Records and Establishes Firmwide Information Governance
This PilotLegis member firm engaged Mattern to address two interconnected risks: a growing off-site records footprint and the absence of a firmwide information governance framework. By pairing a historical records cleanup with practical IG policy development, the firm took a disciplined approach to reducing legacy paper risk while establishing clear, defensible practices for the future. The result was a coordinated strategy that delivered immediate cost and risk reduction while setting the foundation for long-term governance maturity.
Mattern Revamps Nonprofit’s Off-Site Records Program, Cutting Storage Costs by 82%
There is a way out.
Typically, Mattern works with law firms but when a former client called from their new role at a nonprofit and asked for help with a long-troubled off-site records program, Mattern didn’t hesitate. The nonprofit organization had tried for years to improve the situation without success. Mattern stepped in to deliver clarity, competition, and control.
Strategic Scanning Initiative Enables Seamless Office Move for National Law Firm
A national law firm preparing for a major office relocation needed a structured, defensible way to reduce its physical records footprint without disrupting attorney workflows. Mattern designed and managed a comprehensive scanning initiative that aligned with the Firm’s information governance objectives and ensured all work was completed before the move. The result was a streamlined transition that strengthened long-term records management practices.
Future-Ready Legal Operations: How Mattern Helped a Leading Law Firm Optimize Outsourcing, Technology, and Governance
To stay ahead of shifting demands, this California-based NLJ 500 firm needed to align its outsourcing, equipment, and information governance practices with a hybrid work environment. Mattern helped the firm optimize operations, strengthen policy, and secure long-term stability across 12 offices—all while recovering the full cost of the engagement.
.png)










